Match events
Minute by minute- 12'0–1 Goal: Bryan Cristante Atalanta
- 43' Yellow card: Ashley Williams Everton
- Half-time 0–1
- 61' Substitution: Mattia CaldaraOff: Andrea Masiello Atalanta
- 62' Substitution: Nikola VlasicOff: Davy Klaassen Everton
- 63'0–2 Goal: Bryan CristanteAssist: Alejandro Gómez Atalanta
- 67' Yellow card: Cuco Martina Everton
- 69' Substitution: Morgan FeeneyOff: Jonjoe Kenny Everton
- 70' Substitution: Robin GosensOff: Hans Hateboer Atalanta
- 71'1–2 Goal: SandroAssist: Kevin Mirallas Everton
- 76' Yellow card: Tom Davies Everton
- 79' Substitution: Dominic Calvert-LewinOff: Kevin Mirallas Everton
- 82' Substitution: Andreas CorneliusOff: Bryan Cristante Atalanta
- 86'1–3 Goal: Robin Gosens Atalanta
- 88'1–4 Goal: Andreas CorneliusAssist: Mattia Caldara Atalanta
- 90+2' Yellow card: Dominic Calvert-Lewin Everton
- 90+4'1–5 Goal: Andreas CorneliusAssist: Alejandro Gómez Atalanta
Line-ups
Confirmed
Everton4-2-3-13-4-1-2Atalanta
- 33 Robles
- 15 Martina
- 4 Keane
- 5 Williams
- 4369' Kenny
- 26 Davies
- 54 Baningime
- 2062' Klaassen
- 10 Rooney
- 11A79' Mirallas
- 9 Sandro
- 1 Berisha
- 561' Masiello
- 6 Palomino
- 3 Tolói
- 3370' Hateboer
- 11 Freuler
- 482' Cristante
- 21 Castagne
- 15 de Roon
- 10A2 Gómez
- 29 Petagna
Everton bench
- 48Morgan Feeney69'
- 29Dominic Calvert-Lewin79'
- 27Nikola Vlasic62'
Atalanta bench
- 9Andreas Cornelius82'
- 13Mattia Caldara61'A
- 8Robin Gosens70'